Sir Alan Walters, one of Mrs Thatcher’s key economic advisers, has died at the age of 82. Though he always tried to shun media attention, Sir Alan attracted a considerable amount of it when he clashed publicly with the then Chancellor, Nigel Lawson, over the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM). When faced with the choice from Nigel Lawson that either Alan Walters went or he did, Mrs Thatcher famously chose her adviser over her Chancellor. This lent Sir Alan a degree of infamy in economic circles and he is perhaps known best as one of the most influential monetarists of the period. Sir Alan was an early advocate of money supply targeting and always argued that the money supply should not be manipulated for political reasons. His advice was also key in the budget of 1981 which raised taxes in the middle of a recession, something that in this current recession would appear to be unthinkable.
Thatcher’s economic guru dies Independent (6/1/09)
Nigel Lawson and Thatcher’s guru in a political bloodbath Telegraph (5/1/09)
Mrs Thatcher always agreed with Alan Times Online (5/1/09)
Thatcher pays tribute to Walters BBC News Online (5/1/09)
Thatcher economic adviser Walters dies The Herald (6/1/09)
Sir Alan Walters, Thatcher’s economic guru, dies aged 82 Times Online (5/1/09)
Sir Alan Walters Telegraph (6/1/09)
Mrs Thatcher’s monetarist guru The Economist (6/1/09)
Questions
- Write a short paragraph setting out the key influences of Sir Alan Walters on economic policy in the 1980s and 1990s.
- Explain what is meant by money supply targeting.
- Discuss the effectiveness of money supply targeting in combatting inflation in the 1980s.
- Examine whether money supply targeting might once again be an effective tool in the monetary policy ‘armoury’.
In successive months the Monetary Policy Committee of the Bank of England (MPC) has cut Bank Rate from 4.5% down to 2% – the lowest level since November 1951. The dramatic changes show that the Bank is concerned that inflation and economic activity will fall sharply. Indeed the Governor has recognised that there is a possible danger of deflation (defined, in this context, as negative inflation: i.e. a fall in the price index, whether CPI or RPI). To the extent that these cuts in Bank Rate are passed on in interest rate cuts by banks and building socities, they will reduce the cost of borrowing. It is hoped that this, in turn, will result in a boost to aggregate demand – particularly in the run-up to Christmas.
Below is a selection of articles relating to the interest rate cuts, with many commentators wondering if the cuts will be enough and whether interest rates have much lower to go. For some background on interest rates, you may like to look at the History of Britain’s interest rate published by the Times Online. Martin Rowson’s cartoon in the Guardian clearly summarises the view that this may not be enough to revive an ailing British economy!
Bank enters uncharted territory BBC News Online (4/12/08)
Q&A: The Bank Rate cut and you BBC News Online (12/12/08)
Where will interest rates go now? BBC News Online (4/12/08)
Bank of England still has ammunition for the new year Guardian (4/12/08) Video
Farwell, convention Guardian (5/12/08)
No doubt that we’ve got further to go in this rate cutting Guardian (5/12/08) Podcast
Bank cuts rate by 1% to historic low Times Online (4/12/08)
Analysis: Shock and awe of rate cut Times Online (4/12/08)
Rates cut again as recession deepens Times Online (5/12/08)
Unconventional steps may slow the slide into global recession Times Online (7/12/08)
Bank cuts UK rates to 57-year low Times Online (4/12/08)
Questions
Governments around the world have been reacting to the global financial crisis by cutting interest rates in the hope that an expansionary monetary policy will help prevent recession or perhaps minimise the length, depth and severity of recession. In the articles below, we look at interest rate cuts in some countries, but there are many others. Why not use Google news or an equivalent site to try to find some more examples?
Europe
ECB rate cut sets tone for worldwide attempt to spark stalled economies Times Online (5/12/08)
Is the ECB dragging its heels? BBC News Online (4/12/08)
ECB cuts eurozone rates to 2.5% BBC News Online (4/12/08)
Sweden
Sweden, like us, seems to have things in hand Times Online (5/12/08)
Sweden cuts interest rates to 2% BBC News Online (4/12/08)
mesSweden cuts interest rates to 2% BBC News Online (4/12/08)
Australia
Australia cuts interest rates to seven year low Times Online (2/12/08)
Thailand
Large cut in Thai interest rates BBC News Online (3/12/08)
China
China’s central bank cuts rates BBC News Online (26/11/08)
Questions
- Explain the transmission mechanism whereby cuts in interest rates are transmitted to an increase in consumer expenditure.
- Using diagrams as appropriate, show how interest rates are determined in the money markets.
- Discuss the relative effectiveness of monetary policy and fiscal policy in boosting consumer expenditure.
Some economists believe that deflation is now a more serious threat than inflation. If this is the case then conventional monetary policy may not be enough to prevent deflation. In the article below, Gavyn Davies argues that the solution is to start thinking like South American dictators and print more money!
We must start thinking like South American dictators Guardian (13/11/08)
Questions
- Explain what is meant by “deflation”.
- Examine the link between deflation and depression.
- Explain why deflation requires a different policy response from inflation.
- Discuss the likely success of a policy of “printing money” in preventing deflation.
- Assess the impact of financing tax cuts through the sale of government bonds in a deflationary situation.
The potential relevance of Keynesian economic theory has been sharply brought back into focus as governments struggle to find an appropriate mix of policies to try to avoid or mitigate the impact of recession on their economy. Chancellor Alistair Darling has relaxed fiscal rules to allow spending to rise in an attempt to boost aggregate demand and compensate for falling consumer demand.
How to kick start a faltering economy the Keynes way BBC Magazine (22/10/08)
Situation vacant: a theorist is sought to succeed Mr Keynes Guardian (11/10/08)
In praise of ….. John Maynard Keynes Guardian (9/10/08)
Spend, spend, spend: Alistair Darling adopts John Maynard Keynes doctrine Times Online (20/10/08)
Darling invokes Keynes as he eases spending rules to fight recession Guardian (20/10/08)
Follow Gordon Brown again and spend out of recession Times Online (14/10/08)
Economists condemn Chancellor Alistair Darling’s spending plan Telegraph (26/10/08)
Keynes, the man to get the Government out of a crisis The Independent (20/10/08)
Questions
| 1. |
Explain briefly the Keynesian approach to the management of the level of aggregate demand. |
| 2. |
Using diagrams as appropriate, show the impact of the relaxation of fiscal spending rules on the UK economy. |
| 3. |
Discuss the extent to which a Keynesian approach to economic policy is likely to help the government avoid a recession in the UK. Is leaving the control of interest rates in the hands of an independent Bank of England a constraint on the effectiveness of this policy approach? |